seebart wrote: True, electric cars are becoming a realistic option. German car makers have long ignored the subject but are now finally coming out with electric models. We also have quite a car-sharing boom in the cilties here in Germany. I sometimes use some of these services, quite practical for shorter trips.
My city, Indianapolis, is basically serving as experiment for electric car sharing in the United States. We have this service called
Blue Indy, based on the
Autolib service that has been successful in a few large French cities. Indianapolis is a sprawling mess with some of the worst public transport in the country for a city of its size, so the mayor and French billionaire Vincent Bollore decided to use the city as a testing ground (with public funding, of course). The service is intended to fill a convenience gap that the public transport system clearly lacks. Theoretically, if the service is successful in a sprawling American city like Indianapolis, it could work anywhere else.
I use the service a couple times a week, and it is convenient, but like a piece of software that was rolled out too early. Honestly, I think it will fail here, for a couple reasons. 1) Indianapolis is a heavily car centric city with a conversative population that is skeptical of new ideas and also poor people that cannot afford this stuff. Adoption is slow; 2) Reliability is lacking in the system. Broken charging stations, malfunctioning software, super cheap cars, etc. Quality is poor, and if people have a couple bad experiences, they will not continue using it.
Most American cities have too low density to allow effective and reliabile public transportation. Innovative alternatives like electric car sharing deserve to be considered. However, if they are executed poorly, they will not succeed.
webwit wrote: They will have a problem if there aren't any big breakthroughs in battery technology. I wouldn't do
this. They add to the pain by making those batteries and loading stations brand exclusive. What I want is make a pit stop at a generic battery station and swap my battery for a fully charged one.
Yea, super fast charging stations that are not brand exclusive and quick battery swaps will be necessary for electric cars to succeed at a massive level. We are too accustomed to a convenient, quick fill up. Imagine a network of charing stations and battery swaps as common as gas stations. That's what it will take to alleviate "range anxiety."