Alps SKCM Neon Green

[Chyros]

I propose renaming SKCM Green to SKCM Neon Green. It reflects the colour better, draws more attention to the alternative, and avoids the common confusion with SKCL Green. Who's with me?

[derzemel]

I propose renaming SKCM Green to SKCM Neon Green. It reflects the colour better, draws more attention to the alternative, and avoids the common confusion with SKCL Green. Who's with me?

Yes, I agree

[ohaimark]

Yep.

[bocahgundul]

I agree with you!

[ReleaseCandidate]

Too late. You shall _not_ change name that is already established (well, you can, but be prepared to get kicked in the nuts - like that guy that called the SGI keyboards 'bigfoots' if I ever get hold of him).

[scottc]

"That guy" who was probably the foremost authority on Alps weirdness on DT and the biggest wiki contributor to date...

[ReleaseCandidate]

"That guy" who was probably the foremost authority on Alps weirdness on DT and the biggest wiki contributor to date...

I know, but that doesn't matter at all.

[ohaimark]

It doesn't?

In a situation where Alps sliders display a legitimate color difference, an authority on Alps switches endorses the idea, and the new name is damn cool without changing a jot of other information, your opposition seems deliberately and pointlessly contrarian.

[seebart]

For the sake of avoiding common confusion with SKCL Green this makes sense, but let's have some options for that name please. "Neon" is pretty new school shitty disco fluff sounding.

"That guy" who was probably the foremost authority on Alps weirdness on DT and the biggest wiki contributor to date...

I know, but that doesn't matter at all.

Oh really?

[ohaimark]

SKCM Light Green
SKCM Neon Green
SKCM Vomit Green
SKCM Bright Green
SKCM Booger Green
SKCM Envy Green
SKCM Radioactive Green

I could go on, but I won't.

[seebart]

SKCM Neon Green
SKCM Light Green
SKCM Bright Green
SKCM Neo Green
SKCM Pale Green
SKCM Greener
SKCM Chyros Green

[Chyros]

SKCM Chyros Green

I support this proposal .

Although Nubs used the term "neon green" when he discovered the switch :p . Of course, you can have the wiki redirect "SKCM Green" to whatever we choose to rename it. But rename it we must, I think. Lots of switches got renamed, including in the wiki, so why not this one?

[seebart]

Just for good manner I think I contact the mothership about this just to see if I get a response...I bet they have old product specs that we will never get but hey it's worth a try...

http://www.alps.com/e/common/inquiry.html

[ReleaseCandidate]

In a situation where Alps sliders display a legitimate color difference, an authority on Alps switches endorses the idea, and the new name is damn cool without changing a jot of other information, your opposition seems deliberately and pointlessly contrarian.

SKCL and SKCM green have been called 'green' (actually rather 'linear' and 'tactile' green) before most of you even have been born. So yes, it doesn't matter at all.
New names for new stuff is OK, but please restrain from renaming old, long established ones to avoid confusion - or prepare getting kicked in the nuts!

[seebart]

Your posts have a snazzy punk to them you might want to filter down a little. Many of us were born before Alps SKCL / SKCM even existed! How do you know my age, or any age? And nobody is getting "getting kicked in the nuts" here either. You have not been around here very long here I see.

[002]

I don't think they should be renamed either to be honest. Their characteristics alone (linear vs tactile) ought to be enough for someone to figure out which is which. There are other colours that exist in both the SKCL and SKCM lines (brown, cream) so if we were to start referring to the SKCM as Neon Green, shouldn't we be giving the other colours some distinct names too?

[Chyros]

if we were to start referring to the SKCM as Neon Green, shouldn't we be giving the other colours some distinct names too?

That's kind of my point, all of them already do except for Neon Green :p .

Also ReleaseCandidate cool your tits! It's just a name :p .

[002]

all of them already do except for Neon Green

Maybe I missed something but I am not sure what you mean by that

wiki/Alps_SKCL_Brown
wiki/Alps_SKCL_Cream
wiki/Alps_SKCM_Brown
wiki/Alps_SKCM_Cream

[seebart]

We don't even have the "new greens" in our wiki yet, stop calling them neon green please Chyros until we can agree on a name. I just don't like "neon". How does the slider color compare to Alps SKCL Green? Who's got both on hand for color comparison?

[snuci]

I'm 100% behind what 002 said. Seebart, I'll see if I have both.

[002]

Some pics (including comparison) here:
keyboards-f2/xerox-with-tactile-green-alps-t8461.html

I admit I have done no research at all here but given that the SKCM green is rare, could it be simply variance in the dye or whatever or do we have enough real-world examples to say that the colour difference is intentional?

[seebart]

Yeah looking at this the slider color really has some "neonness" to it. Hmm...

Kz27sZ4.jpg (118.21 KiB) Viewed 18112 times

[Khers]

I'm also behind 002 on this.

Had both been SKCLs or SKCMs, I'd have agreed that calling both greens would have been confusing. Since one is SKCL and the other is SKCM, however, I don't see the point of renaming them tbh.

[Chyros]

all of them already do except for Neon Green

Maybe I missed something but I am not sure what you mean by that

wiki/Alps_SKCL_Brown
wiki/Alps_SKCL_Cream
wiki/Alps_SKCM_Brown
wiki/Alps_SKCM_Cream

The colour in SKCL and SKCM browns and creams is quite comparable if not exactly the same. The two shades of green of SKCL and SKCM green are completely different. From what Daniel Beardsmore told me it's not even sure SKCL and SKCM actually stand for linear and tactile.

Seebart; if you want an idea of what the slider colour of SKCM green is, look up "malachite" under shades of green on wikipedia, that captures it fairly closely. Cameras never seem to be able to shot the right colour, probably because they try to compensate for the intensely bright colour.

[002]

My issue with simply comparing the slider colour is that if you look at the example above, it's not just the slider that's completely different, it's the housing as well. Honestly I reckon that when the masterminds behind the colours at Alps discussed this, the conversation would have went something like:

"Should we make this one green?"
"Yeah, mate. Sounds good!"

Not like:

"Should we make this one green?"
"Actually you know what...lets make it malachite!"

I guess the point I'm trying to make is...do Alps even acknowledge the colour of the switches. Is it even that important or is it the switch components that are important and the distinguishing factor between variants?

[seebart]

Right but "malachite" sounds utterly shit. Yes the camera colors vs. real life color problem has been pissing me off for years. The SKCM Blue sliders in my NTC KB 6151 look almost purple in real life. In my Focus the blue sliders are a tiny bit lighter blue. I bet Alps Electric gave a shit about the consistency of the slider colors vs. the switch internals.

I could also imagine that the different slider colors had something to do with the production logistics foremost. Simple visual distinction for sorting along the production process or something similair. No keyboard user ever pulled keycaps in the 1980's or 90's. I remember typing on AEK 2's plenty in the 1990's and obviously not thinking about the keyboard internals.

[Chyros]

Right but "malachite" sounds utterly shit.

Indeed, hence why I suggested neon green instead :p . I just used malachite to give you an indication of what the colour is actually like in the flesh. SKCL green looks almost vomit-coloured, especially by comparison. It appears that Alps always went for some weird off-colour; their pink looks like salmon or vice versa, orange is a very dirty almost red, yellow is very very desaturated, almost like piss but when you've had a fair amount of vitamin C recently.

Maybe "Alps SKCL piss", "Alps SKCM failed pink", "Alps SKCL vomit" and "Alps SKCM not quite red" would make good changes too .

No keyboard user ever pulled keycaps in the 1980's or 90's. I remember typing on AEK 2's plenty in the 1990's and obviously not thinking about the keyboard internals.

Some manufacturers like Northgate encouraged it! They provided keycap pullers and alternate-layout caps you could stick on yourself. IBM possibly intended the same with their two-par keycap design.

[seebart]

Maybe "Alps SKCL piss", "Alps SKCM failed pink", "Alps SKCL vomit" and "Alps SKCM not quite red" would make good changes too

Nope! Pay more respect to the mighty Alps SKCM:

SKCM Light Royal Green
SKCM The Green Lantern
SKCM A Paler Shade Of Green
SKCM Fifty Shades Of Green
SKCM Greenskeeper
SKCM MrGreen

[Chyros]

Maybe "Alps SKCL piss", "Alps SKCM failed pink", "Alps SKCL vomit" and "Alps SKCM not quite red" would make good changes too

Nope! Pay more respect to the mighty Alps SKCM:

SKCM Light Royal Green
SKCM The Green Lantern
SKCM A Paler Shade Of Green
SKCM Fifty Shades Of Green
SKCM Greenskeeper
SKCM MrGreen

You know I love Alps really .

[seebart]

I know you do Chyros, anyone watching your reviews can tell, like so often I was kidding.

But this

8I_zpsbycv6wwp.gif (1.02 KiB) Viewed 18022 times

is ugly as hell. Come on man use some other smiley.

Here's kbdfr's smiley source:

http://cosgan.de/index.php

And we still have not gotten any further in our green Alps SKCM situation. I'd love to get my hands on some old Alps SKCM product catalogs. I think I will send them an official DT request, I wonder if Daniel Beardsmore ever tried that.