Siemens: mechanical or not?

User avatar
Half-Saint

13 Sep 2013, 10:40

http://www.bolha.com/racunalnistvo/tipk ... 1378816706

Someone was selling a board exactly like this one for 10€...

Findecanor

13 Sep 2013, 11:17

I can find no description of the keyboard on the page that you link to.

User avatar
7bit

13 Sep 2013, 11:23

Some are and some are not. I got one which was a rubberdome and I've got 2 which are mechanical.

The keyboard in the photo looks like it is backlit, BTW.
My guess, it is a rubberdome. The 2 Tandberg keyboards I've got are with black foam.

ps: One post at DT and you fall back into your keyboard addiction.
:lol:

Findecanor

13 Sep 2013, 15:21

What photo are you talking about? I still see no photo!

User avatar
7bit

13 Sep 2013, 16:07

Works even without JavaScript:
ImageSee the light/yellow shine between the key caps in the top left rows?

Might be a reflection from the plstic sheet or plastic shell.

Findecanor

13 Sep 2013, 17:14

Doesn't work in Chromium, apparently. Thanks!
I have seen a Tandberg keyboard with keys like that. It had "ICL switches" or something very much like them.

User avatar
7bit

13 Sep 2013, 18:55

Chromium?
:?

You better upgrade to Netscape Navigator!
:ugeek:

ninjadoc

21 Sep 2013, 16:10

7bit wrote:Chromium?
:?

You better upgrade to Netscape Navigator!
:ugeek:
Netscape? Do you mean Mozilla Firefox? Fricking search is broke in the last two versions! Problem with Chrome is it tells Google everywhere you go. Forget that - my business not theirs!!

ZeDolla

29 Sep 2013, 15:49

I'm the owner of the keyboard- the background of the keyboard is all flashy because of my camera, as it is made out of metal. I've gotten a piece of info that suggets that switches use the Rafi-Hall principle to operate. Anyone know anything about this?

User avatar
dorkvader

29 Sep 2013, 22:06

There have been keyboards with similar keycaps that use hall effect switches (cortron/rafi/itw, I don't know, they all look similar to me, and I don't own any yet) however, the same is true for cherry ML. If you were to remove a keycap, we would know (almost) for sure.

That said, I don't know of any metal-plate mounted cherry ML switches, so I doubt it's that.
http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=461 ... #msg974735
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TDV_2200

Note: also no metal plate on the hall effect one
http://deskthority.net/marketplace-f11/ ... ml#p102798

I am sure others know more about this than I, so I'll let them chime in. Until then, pictures or a description of the keyswitches would be excellent.

ZeDolla

29 Sep 2013, 22:34

Pictures with removed keycaps:

http://imgur.com/rvAjTDL,DVsVZfS

User avatar
Daniel Beardsmore

30 Sep 2013, 22:22

ZeDolla wrote:I've gotten a piece of info that suggets that switches use the Rafi-Hall principle to operate. Anyone know anything about this?
I cannot be 100% certain about it, but Rafi is not ruled out. The keycap mounts could be Rafi, ITW/Cortron/Devlin.

I don't recognise the switch, but it's got a lot in common with what I've seen of Rafi. This is the only recorded instance of Rafi Hall effect (RS 76C) to date:

[wiki]RAFI RS 76C[/wiki]

User avatar
Daniel Beardsmore

01 Oct 2013, 00:33

FWIW, I've just e-mailed a link to the big pic to someone at both Devlin and RAFI, to see if either of them know anything about it.

User avatar
Daniel Beardsmore

01 Oct 2013, 01:28

OK, Devlin ruled out.

ZeDolla

01 Oct 2013, 16:25

Thanks man, I really appreciate it :)

User avatar
7bit

01 Oct 2013, 16:30

ZeDolla wrote:Pictures with removed keycaps:

Image
Looks mechanical to me.

edit: Indeed it is.
:-)

Sorry for my misinformaiton before.

There exist keyboards which look the same outside (same key cap design) but are rubberdomes. It is like with G83-3000 keyboards.

Keyfeel is similar to Cherry ML or a bit lighter than blacks.
Attachments
taylorix_102.jpg
taylorix_102.jpg (299.87 KiB) Viewed 12914 times

User avatar
Daniel Beardsmore

01 Oct 2013, 19:48

7bit: interesting, those opaque white switch tops are very RAFI-esque. I'm hoping RAFI can provide the actual part number. (Not sure what Cherry ML switches there are that feel like lighter blacks: my NIB ML switches are distinctly tactile, and very scratchy.)

Any idea what years these keyboards have on them? I'm guessing the switches were discontinued some years ago.

ZeDolla: I don't suppose you have a camera with macro capability and a flash, do you, so we can get a close-up shot of the shiny thing, i.e. are the switches plate mounted? I really can't tell from those photos what I'm looking at.

User avatar
7bit

01 Oct 2013, 19:55

The keyboard is from the late 1980s. People used to say they feel like Cherry ML, or have as low travel as ML.

I remember they felt quite nice, linear like vintage blacks but a bit lighter.

My 105 AiS micro is on the way to me ...
:o

ps: They are not plate mounted.
:P

ZeDolla

01 Oct 2013, 19:57

I'm uploading :)

ZeDolla

01 Oct 2013, 20:04


User avatar
Daniel Beardsmore

01 Oct 2013, 22:59

So what's that, some sort of EM radiation shield?

User avatar
Daniel Beardsmore

10 Nov 2013, 23:54

I tried APC Contech and Bytec (formerly rafi.co.uk), no word from either. I just re-sent both messages, and now Bytec's enquiry e-mail address (listed on their website) has ceased to exist! Just tried their contact form — which just ate my message without a word, which may just be typically rubbish programming.

User avatar
Daniel Beardsmore

04 Dec 2013, 00:48

Any chance of getting to see inside the switch, at least?

I've assigned this switch the ID [wiki]USw UQPW01[/wiki] for now, as I can't be certain whether it's metal contact or electromagnetic, nor do we have a brand confirmation. Slider code Q (square) as I don't know whether it's compatible with Cortron or RAFI mounts or indeed whether RAFI switches use Cortron mounts or whether their mounts have different dimensions.

No word from RAFI at all on this one — radio silence.

User avatar
Daniel Beardsmore

15 Jun 2014, 17:58

Interesting. I came across a Siemens portable computer today (old school 286 PAC-like luggable with 5.25" drive and IIRC a 5.25" HDD) with what appeared to be these switches. (I didn't want to risk pulling a keycap, but I could see what appeared to be the distinctive shape and colour of the switch underneath a keycap.)

I was expecting them to be linear. They were in fact distinctly tactile (more so than MX Brown).

7bit's are linear, so there appear to be two versions of this switch, linear and tactile.

User avatar
OleVoip

05 Feb 2015, 19:38

Tandberg used Siemens-shaped keycaps on Cherry switches, so the keycap is no good indicator.
The switches in 7bit's photos are Siemens STB 21 switches. I've updated Daniel's wiki entry and moved it to "Siemens STB".

User avatar
Daniel Beardsmore

05 Feb 2015, 21:48

Interesting, maybe that's why RAFI didn't say anything.

What makes them tactile — domes under the keycaps, or mechanical tactility?

User avatar
Daniel Beardsmore

05 Feb 2015, 23:47

BTW, if you illustrate the page nicely, I might be forced to issue what would be only the second ever wiki gold star. My other concern is knowing how you know all the details — I'm guessing you have a datasheet that can be scanned in.

User avatar
OleVoip

06 Feb 2015, 00:24

Hi Daniel,

here is a link to a bilingual Siemens catalog from the 1990s, http://www.datasheetarchive.com/dl/Data ... 022194.pdf
The section about the STB switches starts on page 80.

I once opened an STB switch -- the mechanics (and, to my mind, the feel) is similar to Cherry MX brown switches.
The tactile feel comes from the interaction between the slider and the vertical contact leaf.

Kind regards,
Ole

User avatar
002
Topre Enthusiast

06 Feb 2015, 00:33

Daniel Beardsmore wrote: I might be forced to issue what would be only the second ever wiki gold star.
Wait...someone other than you did something on the wiki deserving of praise? I thought you were done with the wiki anyway? I'm sure I've read that about 12 times in the last few weeks...

User avatar
Daniel Beardsmore

06 Feb 2015, 00:36

Whatever I encountered was a lot more tactile than MX brown — pity I can't even remember the name of the computer.

The specifications are surprisingly detailed.

Post Reply

Return to “Keyboards”